Hello dear
Welcome to Mama Sid's Pizza
Welcome to Mama Sid's Pizza, a beloved Athens gem located at 2240 S Barnett Shoals Rd. This cozy eatery offers a delightful variety of pizzas, including standouts like the White Pizza and Mama's Special, which features six toppings for the price of four. The welcoming atmosphere is perfect for families, with friendly staff like Amy and owner Shawn ensuring impeccable service. Diners rave about the fresh, flavorful pizzas and enticing specials, such as the Monday Calzone Special and Wednesday Cheese Pizza deal. Whether you're enjoying a meal with your family or grabbing a slice during the buffet, Mama Sid's Pizza promises a satisfying experience at unbeatable prices.
Today's Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Monday Calzone Special
Diet Coke
Mad Italian Sub
House Salad
About
Mama Sid's Pizza
Welcome to Mama Sid's Pizza, a beloved gem nestled in the heart of Athens, GA, at 2240 S Barnett Shoals Rd. With a welcoming atmosphere and an unwavering commitment to quality, Mama Sid's has become a staple in the region, drawing locals and visitors alike. You can reach them at +1 706-549-6100.
When it comes to pizza, Mama Sid's truly excels. Their signature special, the Kitchen Sink Pizza, is a culinary masterpiece featuring ten toppings at the price of seven—a lavish treat that spans thick crust, pepperoni, beef, and an array of vibrant veggies topped with double cheese. For those seeking something different, the Philly Cheese Steak Pizza offers a delectable twist with sautéed onions adorned by garlic butter, while the Papa's Luau brings the tropical delight of ham and pineapple to your plate. The options extend to both 12" and 16" sizes, catering to every appetite.
Monday specials include a tantalizing Calzone Special, where you can choose two free fillings of your choice for just $7.99. Similarly, Wednesdays feature an unbeatable offer on plain cheese pizzas, providing 12 slices for only $9.19—a perfect option for families or gatherings.
As a food reviewer, I can't help but feel the warm, inviting spirit of Mama Sid’s, accentuated by the kind-hearted staff who make each visit memorable. Customers rave about the friendly service; Jeremy Gentry notes the attentiveness of Amy at the counter and how owner Shawn is always eager to chat. This cozy restaurant strikes an ideal balance between casual dining and a family-friendly experience, an ambiance that brings everyone together. Tasha Grover echoes this sentiment, relishing the delicious s’mores pizza in a genuinely supportive environment.
Those searching for an all-you-can-eat experience won't leave disappointed. Kristi Dorman highlights the amazing value of the pizza buffet, available from 11 AM to 2 PM, making it a perfect midday treat. Even when customers arrive close to closing time, like Morgan Weaver's experience, the service remains impeccable, with the staff eager to prepare fresh pizzas tailored to their tastes.
Mama Sid's Pizza is not just a meal—it's an experience, a place where the aroma of freshly baked pizza fills the air, and laughter echoes off the walls. With affordable prices and generous portions, every slice brings a taste of love and community you won't find anywhere else. If you're in Athens, make sure to drop by Mama Sid's—you won't leave disappointed!
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Mama Sid's Pizza is an Athens staple. We come here a few times a month, and the pizza is always hot, fresh, and delicious. Amy is usually at the counter—she’s kind, attentive, and keeps things running smoothly. Shawn, the owner, is always happy to chat and will serve up whatever kind of pizza you’re craving. You really can’t beat the price. It’s solid food in a cozy, rustic atmosphere—perfect for families. Great place to bring the kiddos! ”
“ Great family restaurant. Our waitress was so nice! My family's favorite was s'mores pizza. Good atmosphere and the food was delicious. ”
“ Amazing pizza honestly. Really cheap pizza buffet at like 7. From (I think) 11am-2pm, dinner starts at 5 but no idea what time it ends. They'll make you any pizza you ask for then putting it on the bar. The staff is super friendly too. I'm sad there's not one in CA because it's my new favorite pizza place!!! ”
“ I am spoiled for Mama Sids pizza after driving from Atlanta to take my sister out for her birthday. All other pizza is mediocre after eating here! I'm an hour and thinking about moving closer. LoL ”
“ We came in looking to try something new and was beyond pleasantly surprised. The waiter was kind, service was fast, and the pizza was fresh and delicious even though we came in 20 minutes before they closed! They asked us our favorite pizzas and then made a fresh one specifically for us. And for two people it was only 14 dollars for unlimited buffet pizza, amazing prices. The interior was well decorated and clean. Would 1000% recommend dining here, and I will be coming back!!! ”
“ Nostalgia! My dad always took me here before we went to Georgia Bulldogs basketball games. The pizza is fantastic and comes in a variety of different types, even dessert pizza (which you cannot leave without trying). The pizza is worth the wait! ”
“ Just as good as it was 20 years ago! From the classics like cheese and pepperoni, to the exotic pizzas like White Feta with Spinach and Tomattos, and the Smores, Apple, and Honey desert pizzas we just love their pizza buffet. I especially like the crispy sourdough like crust. One of my overall favorite pizza stops in all of northeast Georgia. It is also not uncommon to visit with the owners during the week. The kids also marvel at the magic tricks that happen on occasion. If you have never tried them out you will be pleasantly surprised. ”
“ I've been getting takeout from this place for quite a while and they've never failed me. They're super nice and their pizzas are really good. ”